The Black Hole of Job Applications - What silence costs and why expectation is everything.

Aug 4, 2025

You can send 600 CVs and still feel like a ghost.
No reply. No view. No signal you were seen.

 

The Invisible Effort

Every job seeker knows that applying is work. But unless you’ve lived it, really lived it, you don’t understand just how much.

It’s not just clicking "Apply." It’s rewriting the CV for the 17th time that week. It’s reworking a cover letter to match a vague job description for a company that might not even be real.

It’s spending an entire day sending out applications, tailoring each one with care, and walking away with nothing but fatigue and doubt.

Some platforms give you hope. “Application viewed,” “CV downloaded.” Tiny signals of life.

But most don’t. Most vanish. Into a vacuum.

 

A Thousand Times Over

Over the course of a month and a half, I applied to nearly 1,000 jobs. Across industries: medical imports, car sales, finance, operations, logistics. Across titles: Financial Director, Commercial Manager, Ops Lead.

Some jobs were hidden behind third-party portals. Others offered no details at all. A surprising number didn’t even name the company.

Every application took time. Time I couldn’t get back. Hours spent filling in the same fields over and over again, because no two portals talked to each other.

I wasn’t throwing spaghetti at the wall. I used AI to scan my CV and suggest adjacent roles I hadn’t thought of. I widened the net, carefully.

Still, silence.

Not rejection. Silence.

Out of nearly a thousand applications, I received fewer than 30 formal rejections. That means 97% disappeared. No reply. No thank you. No closure.

 

It's Not About Blame

Let me be clear.

This isn’t about calling out founders, HR teams, or recruiters. I’ve been on that side of the table too. I know the inboxes fill up. I know the time pressure is real. I know there are more roles than hours.

Many companies add the same line to every job ad:
“If you do not hear from us within 2 weeks, please consider your application unsuccessful.”

Legally, that’s fine. Operationally, maybe even necessary.

But emotionally?
It creates a black hole.

 

Fatigue Is a Quiet Killer

There’s a difference between rejection and nothing.

Rejection at least gives you direction.
Nothing just leaves you hanging.

Fatigue builds. You tell yourself it’s a numbers game. You try to stay rational.

But eventually, you stop tailoring the CV. You stop rewording the letter. You stop expecting anything at all.

And then worse, you start expecting nothing from yourself.

That’s the cost of silence.

 

The Recruiter Mirage

Out of all the applications, three or four recruiters actually called me.

They told me I looked like a great candidate. They invested real time onboarding me. They painted a compelling picture.

Then: nothing.

This isn’t a hit piece on recruiters. I get it, they’re dealing with a flood. They prioritize candidates who look easy to place. They’re only human.

But the silence after engagement? That’s where the emotional damage happens.

Hope offered. Hope withdrawn.

Even when you tell them, “Don’t worry about keeping me updated, I’ve been on your side, I understand,” you still hope.

And when that hope isn’t answered not even with a “Sorry, no movement”, the fatigue turns into something worse: demoralization.

 

What's Actually Lost

The greatest cost here isn’t economic. It’s human.

Because job seekers aren’t just job seekers. They’re potential employees. Future clients. Brand advocates. Or, in the absence of engagement — none of those things.

How many highly capable people have walked away from entire industries because the process stripped them of dignity?

How many potential hires took a menial role just to escape the mental toll?

How many people, like me, stopped applying altogether, not out of defeat, but exhaustion?

I eventually built my own thing. Others may not.

This isn’t a war for jobs. It’s a slow erosion of trust in the system.

It’s a quiet leak of talent, creativity, and motivation, drip by drip.

There’s no word strong enough to capture it. Not waste. Not loss. Not brain drain. Something colder. Something heavier.

 

What Better Looks Like

Let’s get specific.

The ideal experience doesn’t mean everyone gets the job. Or even a call.

It just means the silence ends.

Here’s what a better version could look like:

  • An honest “no.” One that arrives quickly.

  • A reason. Even a generic one: skill gap, overqualification, cultural mismatch.

  • A suggestion. “Your profile aligns better with [X] roles.”

  • An encouragement. “Here are 3 actions to take if this is the direction you want to grow in.”

  • A resource. Budget-friendly training, free platforms, online certifications.

  • A checkpoint. “If you make these changes, feel free to apply again in 6 months.”

  • A nudge. “These jobs might suit you better in the meantime.”

Not all of this needs to come from a human.
But some version of this needs to exist, for sanity, for clarity, for trust.

 

Expectation Is the Product

Remember how Uber changed the taxi game?

They didn’t add more drivers.
They didn’t speed up traffic.
They didn’t make cars cleaner or cheaper.

They added transparency.
They showed you the driver’s name.
The ETA.
The rating.
The route.

They managed your expectations. That was the real innovation.

It turned confusion into control.

The same principle applies here.

A job seeker doesn’t need a magic wand.
They just need to know where they stand, and where to go next.

 

"It's Just the Game"

Some people shrug this off. “That’s just how hiring works.”

But why?

If we say we value people, dignity, and long-term relationships, how does silence live in that system?

It’s not about being perfect.
It’s about building better defaults.

Even a well-crafted automated rejection, paired with directional guidance, would change everything.

Not because it solves unemployment.
But because it restores clarity.

 

What I'm Building

I’m working on a tool that does exactly this.

It helps hiring teams automate thoughtful, constructive responses to unsuccessful applicants.

It doesn’t just say “No.”
It simulates what the top candidates looked like.
It tells you why you didn’t make the cut.
And it gives you real, practical steps to close the gap.

Think of it like a GPS for job seekers.
You might not be at your destination.
But at least now, you know the route.

This isn’t about AI hype or scaling empathy.
It’s about making the invisible visible.
And giving the next candidate what I wish I had.

 

A Final Thought

This problem isn’t new.
And the solution doesn’t need to be revolutionary.
It just needs to be human.

We’ve normalized silence.
But what we tolerate becomes design.

And what we design becomes culture.

We can do better, not because it’s noble but because it’s smart.

Clearer communication creates better talent pipelines, healthier company reputations, and stronger relationships.

This isn’t fluff.
It’s strategy.

And it starts with expectation.

 

If you’ve ever felt this silence, or contributed to it you’re not alone.
I’m writing more about hiring, talent, and systems that work for both sides.

Join my newsletter or follow along as I build tools that close the loop.

Not with noise.
But with clarity.

Better Matches - Forward Momentum

© 2025 MJB Strategic. All rights reserved.

Logo

thys@mjbstrategic.com

Corlett Drive

Sandton

Gauteng

2196